Century-Old Baseball Card Collection Worth $30,000+ Discovered in Farm House Basement
Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner, Cy Young, Walter Johnson and Christy Mathewson cards surface in Livonia, MI, along with ultra-rare T206 Drum backs
LIVONIA, MI – [11/12/26] – A collection of rare tobacco and candy cards from 1909-12 has turned up after more than 100 years in the basement of a farm house. It includes Hall of Famers Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner, Cy Young, Walter Johnson and Christy Mathewson, along with rare T206 Drum advertisement backs. A Livonia man contacted Throwback Sports Cards for a free appraisal, and the collection is valued at more than $30,000.

A Family Collection, Untouched for a Century
The owner was helping sort through the basement of his family’s farm house when he opened a box holding nearly 200 tobacco and candy cards from the early 1900s. His grandfather, who would have been about 10 years old and growing up in the St. Louis area when the cards were released, had assembled the collection. The basement was packed with other items from the era, since the family never threw anything away.“After discussing the collection over the phone, we knew this was going to be a significant discovery,” said Joe Tee, owner of Throwback Sports Cards. “Fresh tobacco card discoveries are always exciting, and it’s even more special when the cards come directly from the family of the original owner.” Nearly every major star of the era is represented, and the collection includes more than 40 Hall of Famers. Among them are:
Ty Cobb: T206 Red Portrait and Bat Off, plus E102
Honus Wagner: Colgan’s Chips
Christy Mathewson: E102 and 1910 Orange Borders
Walter Johnson: T206 Hands at Chest
Cy Young: E90-1
Tris Speaker: T206
Jack Johnson: 1910 E-UNC Candy

Rare Drum and Carolina Brights Backs
The most surprising finds were not about the players but about the advertisements on the backs. T206 cards came with one of 16 advertisement backs, and some are extremely scarce. Drum and Carolina Brights are among the rarest. The collection contained two Drum backs (Heinie Wagner and Orval Overall) and one Carolina Brights back (Jean Dubuc). According to the PSA population report, only one other Wagner Drum back has ever been graded.
Collection Highlights
1909-11 T206 White Border: Ty Cobb (Red Portrait, Bat Off), Walter Johnson (Hands at Chest), Tris Speaker, Frank Chance (portrait), Ed Walsh, Chick Gandil, two Drum backs and one Carolina Brights back
1909 E102 set: 22 of the 25 cards in the set, including Ty Cobb, Christy Mathewson, Nap Lajoie, Johnny Evers, Joe Tinker, Eddie Collins, Sam Crawford, Chief Bender and Hal Chase
1909 Colgan’s Chips: Honus Wagner, Hal Chase, Frank Chance
1909-11 E90 American Caramel: Cy Young, Johnny Evers, Frank Chance
1910 Orange Borders: Christy Mathewson, Eddie Plank
1910 E96 Philadelphia Caramel: Connie Mack, Mordecai “Three-Finger” Brown (x2), Hughie Jennings, Nap Lajoie
1910 E-UNC Candy: Jack Johnson
Selling Sports Cards in Metro Detroit
Throwback Sports Cards offers free appraisals and routinely travels around Metro Detroit to appraise and purchase vintage sports card collections. To schedule an appraisal, call or text 734-931-0461, email info.throwbacksportscards@gmail.com, or fill out an appraisal form at www.throwbacksportscards.com.
About Throwback Sports Cards
Throwback Sports Cards is a Michigan-based buyer of vintage sports card collections, providing free appraisals and in-person visits across Metro Detroit.
Contact Us
Throwback Sports Cards
734-931-0461





Comments