top of page
20181121_101514.jpg

Complete "Shoeless" Joe Jackson Baseball Card Price Guide: 1909-1940

Discover the most valuable "Shoeless" Joe Jackson cards produced by American Caramel, Old Mill, Cracker Jacks, & More

There are few names in baseball who carry a more mythical connotation with them than "Shoeless" Joe Jackson. Part of it is because of the nickname, and the other part of what could have been.  Legend has it that Jackson was trying to break in a new pair of cleats during a mill game, but he got blisters so bad he end up having to play barefoot.  This site caused a spectator to yell "You shoeless son of a gun!" And the nickname stuck. Jackson is widely regarded as one of the premier hitters of all time.  Even Ty Cobb said Jackson was "The greatest natural hitter I have ever seen".  Jackson played for the Athletics, Naps, and Whitesox, and everywhere he went he hit.  In 1911 he hit .408 for the Naps.  Jackson's legacy took an unfortunate turn during the 1919 World Series, when he and 7 other teammates got involved with gamblers and decided to throw the World Series. This came to be known as the "Black Sox Scandal". There was some question as to the extent Jackson actually took part in the fix, as he set a then series record with 12 hits.  Jackson admitted to taking money but not throwing any games. Whatever the case, the commissioner of baseball imposed a lifetime ban of "Shoeless Joe".  Even in his last season as a professional, Jackson batted .382.  His lifetime batting average of .356 is still a record.  In 2025, MLB pardoned him, which now makes him eligible for the Hall of Fame.

1909-11 American Caramel E90-1 Joe Jackson #56

Card Value: An SGC 3 sold for $158,000 at Heritage Auctions in 2025

1910 T210 Old Mill Series 8 Joe Jackson

Card Value: An SGC 2 sold for $378,000 at Heritage Auctions in 2025

1910 Schmelzer Sporting Goods Pin Joe Jackson

Card Value: An ungraded pin sold for $10,000 at Heritage Auctions in 2017

1912 Colgan’s Chips Tin Tops Joe Jackson

Card Value: A PSA 2 sold for $15,600 at Goldin Auctions in 2018

1914 B18 Blanket Joe Jackson

Card Value: an ungraded example sold for $1,200 at REA in 2024

1913 Fatima Cleveland Americans Team Card

Card Value: low grade $1500, mid grade $2500+

1914 Boston Garter Joe Jackson #6

Card Value: An SGC 1.5 sold for $252,000 at Heritage Auctions in 2023

1913 National Game Joe Jackson

Card Value: A PSA 7 sold for $6,600 at REA in 2024

1914 Cracker Jack Joe Jackson #103

Card Value: A PSA 2.5 sold for $225,000 at Heritage Auctions in 2025

1914 E and S Publishing Company Joe Jackson

Card Value: A PSA 4.5 sold for $28,800 at Heritage Auctions in 2021

1914 Polo Ground Game Joe Jackson

Card Value: A PSA 6 sold for $5,000 at REA in 2025

1915 Cracker Jack Joe Jackson #103

Card Value: An SGC 3.5 sold for $84,000 at REA in 2025

1915 W-UNC Strip Card Joe Jackson (blank back)

Card Value: No recent sales; likely $25,000+

1916 BF2 Ferguson Bakery Joe Jackson

Card Value: an ungraded example sold for $3,500 at REA in 2024

1916 Famous and Barr Co. Joe Jackson #86

famous and barr back clear.jpeg

Card Value: An SGC 2 sold for $26,400 at REA in 2024

1916 Globe Clothing Store Joe Jackson #87

the-globe-clothing-back.webp

Card Value: no recent sales

1916 Indianapolis Brewing Joe Jackson #87

indianapolis-brewing-back.webp

Card Value: no recent sales

1916 M101-4 Sporting News Joe Jackson #87

m101-4 back_edited.jpg

Card Value: A PSA 7 sold for $97,600 at Heritage Auctions in 2025

1916 M101-5 Sporting News Joe Jackson (blank back)

1917 Boston Store Joe Jackson #82

Card Value: A PSA 8 sold for $84,000 at Heritage Auctions in  2017

Card Value: An SGC 5.5 sold for $49,200 at REA in 2021

1917 Collins-McCarthy Joe Jackson #82

Card Value: A PSA Authentic sold for $36,600 at Heritage Auctions in 2025

1919 W514 Strip Card Joe Jackson #15

Card Value: A PSA 2 sold for $12,000 at Heritage Auctions in 2024

1921 Holsum Bread Joe Jackson

Card Value: A PSA 1 sold for $10,800 at REA in 2018

1940 Play Ball Joe Jackson #225

Card Value: low grade $3,000 to $5,000, mid grade $8,000+

Interested in finding out the value of your Joe Jackson cards?

Send us a description and images of your collection for a free appraisal

Joe Jackson Baseball Card Checklist 1909-1921

1909 American Caramel #56

1910 Old Mill Series 8 

1910 Schmelzer Sporting Goods Pin 

1910 T210 Old Mill Pin 

1912 Colgan’s Chips Tin Tops 

1913 Fatima Cleveland Americans Team Card

1913 National Game 

1914 B18 Blanket

1914 Boston Garter #6

1914 Cracker Jack #103

1914 E and S Publishing Company

1914 Polo Ground Game

1915 Cracker Jack #103

1915 W-UNC Strip Card 

1916 BF2 Ferguson Bakery 

1916 Famous and Barr Co. #86

1916 Globe Clothing Store #87

1916 Indianapolis Brewing #87

1916 M101-4 Sporting News #87

1916 M101-5 Sporting News 

1917 Boston Store #82

1917 Collins-McCarthy #82

1919 W514 Strip Card #15 

1921 Holsum Bread 

1940 Play Ball #225

bottom of page